A housing decision. Four perspectives.

Rent or buy?
Use the Cash Flow Compass.

Look beyond the house payment. Explore borrowing costs, ownership expenses, existing debt, and the freedom you want to keep.

For renters considering a home purchase and homeowners weighing what to do with extra cash. My Cash Flow Compass helps you see the tradeoffs—not just a yes or no.

Start with your numbers ↓

Watch the conversation

A home is more than a payment.

Watch my rent-or-buy discussion, then use your own numbers below. You can pause the video and come back as you work through the four readings.

Before you begin

Bring your numbers. Keep your options.

Have your current rent, annual spending and savings, a home price and mortgage quote, estimated ownership costs, and loan balances handy.

  1. Replace the sample figures. They are examples, not current quotes or personalized estimates. Remove any example loans you do not have.
  2. Work through Cost, Freedom, Flow, and Feel. Use the question-mark buttons for help with each field.
  3. Select “Show me my reading.” Review the tradeoffs, then change one assumption at a time to see what moves the result.

Know what you’re comparing: the Freedom reading covers ownership costs before mortgage principal and interest. It is not your total monthly housing payment or a full rent-versus-buy projection.

Start with an example—or your own numbers.

Example mode: the figures and loans below are samples.

Reading 1

Cost

Money always costs something. If you pay cash, you give up whatever that cash could have earned. If you borrow, you pay interest. One of those two numbers is bigger, and that tells you what to do.

The average 30-year loan was 6.66% on July 30, 2026
This is the rate on your mortgage, or the rate a bank is offering you. If you already have a loan, use that rate.
The chunk of cash you’re deciding what to do with. Your down payment, or extra money you’re thinking about throwing at the loan.
Use what you actually get, not what a brochure promises
Where else could this money go, and what does that pay you? A savings account, an investment, a policy, your own business. Use the real number after fees, not the best year you ever had.
About 9 out of 10 people answer No
Itemizing means you list out deductions instead of taking the standard one. If you don’t know, the answer is almost certainly No. And if it’s No, the mortgage interest write-off you’ve heard about does nothing for you.
The percentage you pay on your last dollar of income. Common ones are 12, 22, 24 and 32. Only matters if you answered Yes above.
If your money grows somewhere, the government usually takes a cut. Long-term investment gains are often 15%. Put 0 if it grows tax free, like in a Roth.
Reading 2

Freedom

Every dollar you spend each year is a dollar you have to save up before you can stop working. A house adds a lot of those dollars, so it moves your finish line.

Food, gas, insurance, kids, travel, rent, all of it. A rough number is fine. If you don’t know, take your monthly spending and multiply by 12.
What you pay now for a place to live. We subtract this, because buying replaces it.
Money you put away and don’t spend. This tells you how many extra years of work the house costs you.
25 is the common rule of thumb
How many years of expenses you’d want in the bank before you’d feel free. Most people use 25. Use a smaller number if you plan to keep earning, a bigger one if you want extra cushion.
US average was $4,427 in 2025
What the city or county charges you every year for owning the place. It’s on every listing, and it goes up over time.
Average was $2,948 in 2025, up 12% in one year
Insurance on the building itself. This has been rising fast, so don’t assume today’s quote holds.
Put 0 if there’s no HOA
A fee some neighborhoods and condo buildings charge for shared upkeep. About 44% of listings have one, and where they exist the middle amount is $135 a month.
What you’d pay for it. We use this to estimate repairs, since bigger and pricier homes cost more to keep up.
1% for a newer home, up to 4% for one over 30 years old
Roof, water heater, furnace, paint, the sprinkler that breaks on a Tuesday. Nobody budgets for this and it’s the number one thing buyers regret. Fannie Mae says 1% to 4% of the price every year.
A house is usually bigger than an apartment, so heating, cooling and water cost more. Guess the difference, not the total.
Reading 3

Flow

Take what you owe on a loan and divide it by the payment. A small number means that loan is squeezing your monthly cash hard, so it gets your attention before anything else.

Reading 4

Feel

How you sleep is a real input. If a loan would keep you up at night, weigh that above the math. That is a legitimate answer.

Zillow worked out how many years you’d have to own in each city before buying beats renting. Pick the closest one to you.
Pick the realistic number. Job changes, kids, and family moves all shorten this. Most people overestimate.
A house payment is the same every month whether you had a good month or not. The less steady your income, the heavier that payment feels.
Six is the floor before you buy anything
If your income stopped tomorrow, how many months could you cover? This is separate from your down payment. Draining this to buy is the most common way a good purchase turns bad.
5
1 = it keeps me up at night    10 = it’s just another bill
There’s no right answer. Some people carry a loan and never think about it. Others feel it every day. Knowing which one you are is worth more than a percentage point.
What do you actually want, before anybody shows you a spreadsheet. This one counts.

Make sense of your reading

One example. A clearer question.

Suppose you are deciding what to do with $100,000. Your loan costs 6%, and that cash could earn 4% after taxes elsewhere. With no mortgage-interest tax adjustment, the Cost reading shows a two-percentage-point gap: about $2,000 a year.

That is an annual rate comparison—not a full loan payoff schedule or a guaranteed investment return. Before moving the money, ask: how much cash would I still have available? Then check ownership expenses, other loans, and how long you expect to stay.

What the four readings measure

Cost · Borrowing versus keeping cash
Compares the entered loan rate with the alternative return, using the tax percentages you enter. The difference is multiplied by the cash amount. The tax adjustment is simplified; itemizing does not necessarily make all mortgage interest deductible.
Freedom · The costs beyond the mortgage
Adds property tax, insurance, HOA dues, maintenance, and extra utilities. It replaces rent with those costs in your annual spending, then applies your selected savings multiple. Mortgage payments, transaction costs, appreciation, and future rent changes are not included in this reading.
Flow · The pressure from existing loans
Divides each loan balance by its monthly payment and sorts the scores from lowest to highest. A lower score means more monthly payment relative to the balance. Explore the Cash Flow Index formula and calculator for a worked example.
Feel · Your flexibility and comfort
Combines your expected time in the home, income stability, reserves, and comfort with debt with the tool’s saved location benchmarks. These are directional assumptions, not live local forecasts or a prediction of your personal break-even date.

Your questions, answered

Cash Flow Compass FAQs

Who is the Cash Flow Compass for?

Renters considering buying a home and homeowners comparing borrowing costs with other uses for their cash. It brings financial inputs and personal preferences into the same conversation.

Does this tell me whether to rent or buy?

It highlights tradeoffs; it does not make the decision for you. In particular, the Freedom reading excludes mortgage principal and interest. Compare the complete payment, transaction costs, and your plans before making a housing decision.

What if I do not know an exact number?

Start with a realistic estimate, then replace it with a lender quote, insurance quote, property-tax estimate, or your actual spending. Run a higher-cost scenario as well. Do not treat the prefilled sample figures as current market prices.

How do I compare two scenarios?

Run your first set of figures, note the four readings, then change one assumption and run it again. For example, compare a higher maintenance budget or a shorter stay. Changing one thing at a time makes the tradeoff easier to understand.

Is the Freedom reading a retirement plan?

No. It multiplies annual spending by your chosen savings multiple and compares the change with annual savings. It does not model investment growth, inflation, withdrawal taxes, or a complete retirement strategy.

What should I do with the result?

Use it to identify the questions that matter most: the cash you would keep, costs you may have missed, debt payments, and flexibility. Review those assumptions with the appropriate financial, mortgage, or tax professional before acting.

Check the assumptions behind your numbers

The tool contains historical example figures and saved location benchmarks; they do not refresh automatically. Use local quotes and actual bills where possible.

Keep exploring: how mortgages work · more money-decision tools.

Where the numbers come from. How long until buying beats renting, Zillow Research, June 2026. Loan rates, Freddie Mac, week of July 30, 2026. Property tax, ATTOM, 2025. Insurance, Insurify, 2025. HOA dues, Realtor.com, 2025. Repair guidance, Fannie Mae. How many people itemize, Tax Policy Center.

What this is not. It is not advice and it does not tell you what to do. It shows you the four costs of a decision most people only count one of, and then it tells you exactly what would have to change for your answer to flip. The walking is still yours.

Explore more from Garrett ↗